Aggravated Felony. The Second Circuit held that a state law drug conviction for a small quanity of marijuana was not an aggravated felony, warranting deportation. To make such a determination, the court looked to whether the offense was equivalent to felony drug traficking under the federal Controlled Substance Act ("CSA"). The CSA has an exception for the distribution of small amounts of mariuana without remuneration, treating it as a misdemeanor. The Court held that the petitioner in this case had not committed an aggravated felony because the crime fell within the CSA exception.

The decision in Martinez v. Mukasey can be found here.

No New Hearing. In a habeas proceeding, the district rejected the credibility determinations of the magistrate judge without holding a separate evidentiary hearing. Not a good idea. The Second Circuit vacated the ruling (granting the habeas relief) and remanded it to the district court for further proceedings.

The decision in Carrion v. Smith can be found here.